Civil government as we know it will be in shambles before 2001 rolls around. The ability of governments above the local level to extract wealth from those under their jurisdiction will be reduced dramatically. Their ability to monitor people will also be reduced. Government will be placed on a starvation diet by the Millennium Bug. While they will no doubt issue executive orders, declare martial law, and all the other things governments do in a crisis, they will be hampered by one crucial fact: bankrupt banks. If governments can't write checks, they cannot maintain their sovereignty. They are creatures of the banks as surely as the banks are creatures of the government. The symbiotic relationship of government-licensed banks and debt-addicted governments is about to end. Both institutions are today completely dependent on reliable computers.
Governments write checks. Taxpayers and investors in government debt write checks to governments. On this bank-enabled two-way relationship hangs the modern world's political order. This relationship will end by the middle of the year 2000. Maybe sooner.
All of the industrial world's tax collectors rely on computers to "follow the money." The state rests on "voluntary compliance" of taxpayers. Taxpayers pay "voluntarily" because they know that their monetary income can be traced by tax collectors who use computers. They fear the tax collector because they fear the tax collector's computer.
This fear will end by the middle of the year 2000. Maybe sooner.
The ability of the state to buy votes, assuage consciences, hire armies, and throw the fear of man into other men today rests on the existence of computers. This ability will end, all over the industrialized world, in the year 2000.
Every government will deny this up until 1999. "We will still be able to get you after 1999. Pay no attention to the little man behind the curtain."
What happened to the Soviet Union in 1991 will happen to all Western governments no later than 2000. The governments' moral claim on the public's obedience -- legitimacy -- will end the day that the banks close. If the government can't send monthly checks to granny for two months in a row, the moral claims of the welfare state die.
The day that granny moves in with sonny and his wife because the government can't make good on its promises, the West's political order will go through a revolution comparable to what Mr. Gorbachev experienced.
The West's politicians haven't a clue as to what is coming. Like Dilbert's boss, they don't worry about the details of programming. (Much as I enjoy reading "Dilbert," that cartoon strip faces a major problem: It won't be funny after 1999.)
All politicians should get an interlibrary loan copy of Roberto Vacca's THE COMING DARK AGE (1974). The section on the ultimate traffic jam is quite good, especially when you think of Los Angeles without synchronized traffic lights.
But if they really want to know what's coming, they should read P. A. Sorokin's THE CRISIS OF OUR AGE (1941) and MAN AND SOCIETY IN CALAMITY (1942). Sorokin founded Harvard's sociology department. They don't read Sorokin at Harvard any more, or anywhere else. They should.
Any modern government that cannot write a check or cash a check is no longer in business. If it can't pay its army or its mailmen, it's doomed. If the tax collector can't send out notices of deficiency, or if the recipient's bank is closed, it's "Game Over."
Updated - |
Subject
|
21-Jan-97 |
Mainframe Readiness Falls Behind Schedule |
30-Jan-97 |
Government-Recommended Criteria for Year 2000 Compliance |
24-Feb-97 |
Treasury Department's Vulnerability |
24-Feb-97 |
$2.3 Billion to Fix U.S. Gov't: Low-Ball Estimate |
24-Feb-97 |
Year 2000 Compliance Survey, U.S. Gov. (1996): Bad News |
24-Feb-97 |
Nebraska's Guidelines for Repairs: Frighteningly Complex |
24-Feb-97 |
"Don't Expect Congress to Pay a Dime!" |
24-Feb-97 |
One County's Programmer Fights for Its Survival |
06-Mar-97 |
A Gigantic Problem, Says a Key Government Science Agency |
19-Mar-97 |
The U.S. Government Has No Agreed-Upon Date Standard |
25-Mar-97 |
State Governments' Bill: $40-60 Billion (Conservative) |
08-Apr-97 |
North Carolina's Y2K Bill: From $7 Million to $300 Million |
05-May-97 |
Oregon's y2k Site Warns: 1997 Is Very Late |
28-May-97 |
Government Admits Truth: Its Computers May Shut Down |
29-May-97 |
Sen. Moynihan's Y2K Bill |
09-Jun-97 |
2/3 of the States Have Not Completed Stage One: 4/21/97 |
10-Jun-97 |
Texas Will Pay $65,000/year to Save the State |
19-Jun-97 |
State Governments' Repair Cost (Salaries Only): $75 billion |
25-Jun-97 |
G-7 Nations Propose a 2-Day Y2K Workshop in 1998 (Wow!) |
26-Jun-97 |
Australia: "Yes, We Have Committees!" |
27-Jun-97 |
California's White Paper Describes a Gigantic Challenge |
02-Jul-97 |
Federal Government: Way Behind |
08-Jul-97 |
Partially Compliant (Sort of), Say 7 States |
11-Jul-97 |
If This Is the Good News, Kiss the Feds Goodbye |
12-Jul-97 |
Assessment Deadline Missed: Treasury, Defense |
14-Jul-97 |
Reduce Welfare AND Fix the Millennium Bug, Too!!! |
16-Jul-97 |
Where Gov't Agencies SAY They Are in the Y2K Process |
16-Jul-97 |
NOW READ THIS!!! The Good News Is Really Bad, Says GAO |
16-Jul-97 |
71% of Mission-Critical Systems Are Unrepaired |
28-Jul-97 |
California: Nowhere Near Compliant |
06-Aug-97 |
U.S. Treasury: No Checks Accepted (1999) |
11-Aug-97 |
GAO Warns of Major High Risk Areas |
12-Aug-97 |
States Fear the Feds' Computers |
12-Aug-97 |
National Science Foundation: Get Compliant, or Else! |
14-Aug-97 |
North Platte, Nebraska: Will Dick Brich Make It? |
16-Aug-97 |
The Clintons on the Year 2000: Bug-Free! |
20-Aug-97 |
White House Public Relations Letter on Y2K |
22-Aug-97 |
Small County Takes an Estimated $6 Million Hit |
25-Aug-97 |
Bureaucrats Admit That Y2K Won't Be Fixed: Chaos Looms |
25-Aug-97 |
Society Could Be Dismantled, Warns Expert |
27-Aug-97 |
New York Governor Issues Y2K Executive Order |
03-Sep-97 |
Canada Sets Up a Y2K Committee: Will Report Next June |
03-Sep-97 |
North Platte, Nebraska: Nip and Tuck |
17-Sep-97 |
OMB Report: Government Is Falling Behind |
17-Sep-97 |
New York's Governor Says, Fix It Now! |
19-Sep-97 |
Congressman Horn's Mid-Term Grades: Poor |
19-Sep-97 |
Lunacy: Deadline Date is November, 1999 |
20-Sep-97 |
Over Half of the U.S. Systems Reported as Repaired Weren't |
24-Sep-97 |
Los Angeles Schools: An Extra $30 to $52 Million |
25-Sep-97 |
Britain's Lapsed Y2K Bill -- Victim of an Election Year |
01-Oct-97 |
Key Problem: Coordinating the Solutions |
01-Oct-97 |
Minnesota: 83m Lines of Code, 50 Languages |
01-Oct-97 |
U.S. Postal Service Is Not Compliant |
06-Oct-97 |
AMERICAN SPECTATOR Warns of a Computer Catastrophe |
06-Oct-97 |
Connecticut's Web Page: A Few Missing Items |
06-Oct-97 |
Connecticut: When Is the Deadline for Starting Code Repair? |
08-Oct-97 |
Canadian Government: Breakdown of Services Possible |
10-Oct-97 |
How Is YOUR State Doing? A Comparison |
13-Oct-97 |
California's Governor Issues Y2K Executive Order |
22-Oct-97 |
Will Florida Make It? |
22-Oct-97 |
Will Jacksonville, Florida, Make It? |
22-Oct-97 |
Britain's Solution: Turn Unemployed Youths into Programmers |
22-Oct-97 |
Yes, Virginia, There is a Y2K Problem: An Extra $50 Million |
22-Oct-97 |
New Software Is Always Buggy: Another Time Constraint |
22-Oct-97 |
Nevada Law: You Can't Sue Nevada Over Y2K |
24-Oct-97 |
Canadian Government Cannot Fix All of Its Systems, Says Official |
24-Oct-97 |
50% of US Agencies Will Not Complete Their Repairs |
24-Oct-97 |
At Last! Some Good News! |
27-Oct-97 |
Canada: Way Behind |
30-Oct-97 |
Britain's Local Governments Are Way Behind |
30-Oct-97 |
Electronic Funds Transfer, 1999: Blueprint for Disaster |
30-Oct-97 |
Pennsylvania's Governor Sounds Emergency Warning |
30-Oct-97 |
Pennsylvania: 21% of the Y2K Project is Finished |
31-Oct-97 |
Singapore Government Funds Private Y2K Repairs |
06-Nov-97 |
European Governments Will Not Meet Deadline, Says Gartner Group |
08-Nov-97 |
European Agences: Near Paralysis on Y2K -- Doing Nothing |
08-Nov-97 |
All Systems Must Be Both Y2K Compliant and Coordinated |
20-Nov-97 |
Britain: 3 of 16 Departments Will Complete Audits on Schedule |
20-Nov-97 |
West Virginia to Seek Legal Immunity: $500 Million in Law Suits Expected |
22-Nov-97 |
New York: 0 of 81 Agencies Have Made an Inventory |
24-Nov-97 |
Clinton Knows About Y2K, Says London Sunday Times |
25-Nov-97 |
Killer Viruses in 2000: Will the CDC Be Compliant? |
25-Nov-97 |
Texas: $400 Million Needed; Legislature Has Allocated $110 Million |
01-Dec-97 |
Texas Government's Retention Problem: Programmers |
01-Dec-97 |
British Government Forms New Committees, Seeks Reports |
01-Dec-97 |
A Y2K Web Site for the British Government |
04-Dec-97 |
Governments in the U.S. Are Way Behind, Summit Meeting Reveals |
04-Dec-97 |
The Official Timetable |
09-Dec-97 |
Michigan Claims 29% Compliance |
15-Dec-97 |
Agency Completion Dates: 2000 to 2019 |
27-Dec-97 |
OMB's November Progress Report: Not Nearly Enough |
27-Dec-97 |
State by State Comparison |
29-Dec-97 |
British Agencies: Barely at Assessment Stage |
06-Jan-98 |
New Zealand's Police Computer Starts Acting Up |
06-Jan-98 |
Some Federal Agencies Will Not Make It: Continency Plans Needed |
06-Jan-98 |
Will Federal Agencies Survive? |
13-Jan-98 |
Georgia Has Barely Begun Its Repairs |
13-Jan-98 |
New York State Faces a Crisis, Says Official |
13-Jan-98 |
Will Repaired Systems Work Together? Hardly Anyone Is Asking |
16-Jan-98 |
Australian Conference: Bad News All Around |
16-Jan-98 |
Sally Katzen Quits as Y2K Flak |
17-Jan-98 |
Australia's Auditor General Says Risks Are Huge |
17-Jan-98 |
Over 50% of U.S. Agencies Will Not Make It, Says Report |
20-Jan-98 |
Australia: It's None of the Public's Business! |
23-Jan-98 |
Governments Will Not Meet Deadline, Say Experts |
04-Feb-98 |
Y2K Expert Calls on Clinton to Draft Gore |
04-Feb-98 |
56% of Texas State Agencies Refuse to Answer |
05-Feb-98 |
Kappelman to Clinton: Global Emergency |
05-Feb-98 |
Clinton Issues a Y2K Executive Order |
10-Feb-98 |
Clinton's Happy Face Web Site on 2000 |
11-Feb-98 |
A Terminally Naive Government Official: "No Excuses for Failure!" |
17-Feb-98 |
Y2K Will Be Discussed at May Summit. A Breakneck Pace! |
18-Feb-98 |
Tennessee: 10+ Years of Work and It's 2/3rds Finished |
20-Feb-98 |
17-Fold Increase in Estimated Cost for Repair: California |
22-Feb-98 |
No Way to Fix US Gov't Computers, Warns Computer Specialist |
22-Feb-98 |
Red China Understands Y2K's Threat to the West: A Link to My Web Site |
23-Feb-98 |
Massachusetts: Way Behind |
24-Feb-98 |
A Compliant County: 2 Mainframes |
26-Feb-98 |
OMB Pushes Up Deadline to March, 1999 |
27-Feb-98 |
White House Computers Are in Chaos Now -- Pre-2000 |
02-Mar-98 |
Oregon's Governor Signs Executive Order |
03-Mar-98 |
U.S. Mails: Nothing Specific, But Don't Worry |
09-Mar-98 |
Local Governments: Half Have No Clue |
09-Mar-98 |
Cong. Horn Hands Out Grades, Mostly Bad |
09-Mar-98 |
Illinois: Not Even Close |
09-Mar-98 |
US Treasury May Not Meet Deadline, Says Rubin |
09-Mar-98 |
Why New York Won't Make It: Salaries |
10-Mar-98 |
New York Faces a Disaster |
10-Mar-98 |
Weymouth, MA Is a Typical Small Town: Way Behind |
10-Mar-98 |
The Nations of the World: Some Bad, Some Worse |
10-Mar-98 |
US Counties: Asleep at the Wheel |
11-Mar-98 |
Australian Government Will Not Correct Everything, Says Y2K Expert |
11-Mar-98 |
Al Gore Warns Cabinet: One of Them Will Be Held Responsible in 2000 |
11-Mar-98 |
National Weather Service Isn't Compliant |
11-Mar-98 |
Public Utility Officials in Wales Seek Contingency Plans |
11-Mar-98 |
Britain's Y2K Official Seeks National Contingency Plans |
13-Mar-98 |
British Government Loses Momentum; Emergency Threatens, Says Guenier |
20-Mar-98 |
Office of Management & Budget Report on Y2K |
21-Mar-98 |
Australia: From Mid-1998 to Mid-1999 |
21-Mar-98 |
Canadian Government: No New Initiatives, Y2K Only |
06-Apr-98 |
Ireland's Government Will Make It, Says Official |
06-Apr-98 |
Executive Order: NSC to Take Over Government |
07-Apr-98 |
Denial in Action: No Problem in Wyoming! |
07-Apr-98 |
Massachusetts Discovers Y2K: $20 Million Bill |
08-Apr-98 |
Expert Warns Congress: Not Enough Resources to Meet Deadline |
15-Apr-98 |
Y2K Is Nearly Solved: U.S. Government Will Soon Form a Council |
16-Apr-98 |
Shortage of Mainframe Programmers Hits U.S. Government |
16-Apr-98 |
U.S. Senate Creates a Special Committee on Y2K |
16-Apr-98 |
Australia: Not Finished With Y2K Audits Yet |
17-Apr-98 |
British Parliamentary Science Committee Warns of Crisis |
17-Apr-98 |
New York's Y2K Project Accomplishments: List Ends in Aug. '97 |
18-Apr-98 |
General Accounting Office Calls for Contingency Plans |
20-Apr-98 |
New Zealand Government Report: A Wish List to Avoid a Disaster |
20-Apr-98 |
New Zealand Government Report: How Bad a Crisis? |
21-Apr-98 |
Georgia Budgets $91 Million. Not Enough, Says Expert |
23-Apr-98 |
U.S. Department of Labor: Nowhere Near Compliant |
23-Apr-98 |
Canadian Agencies Have to Sign Up a Single Y2K Repair Team |
28-Apr-98 |
Huge Y2K Committee, Guaranteeing Failure |
29-Apr-98 |
Intel's President Warns of a Looming Government Crisis |
30-Apr-98 |
Toxic Catastrophe: A Y2K Water Utility Test |
01-May-98 |
New York State Y2K Funding Is Cut |
01-May-98 |
Senator Bennett Says It's Too Late to Fix Everything |
01-May-98 |
Taiwan's Government: 280,000 Programs; Industry: 1,000,000 |
01-May-98 |
Going Under Down Under: Australia's Government |
02-May-98 |
Australia's Civil Defense Prepares for Y2K |
02-May-98 |
U.S. Civil Defense: R.I.P. |
04-May-98 |
List of State Y2K Coordinators |
06-May-98 |
Military Specialist Says Al Gore Is Not Facing the Y2K Reality |
07-May-98 |
Senator Bennett Introduces S. 2000 |
07-May-98 |
One Government Agency's Solution to Y2K: Workshops |
07-May-98 |
Monitoring the Titanic: The Games Bureaucrats Play |
09-May-98 |
Senate Y2K Committee Will Study the Problem |
11-May-98 |
To Prevent Public Panic, Y2K Czar Maintains a Happy Face |
11-May-98 |
European Bureaucrats Meet for First Time to Discuss Y2K |
12-May-98 |
Moynihan's Bill Reduces Supply of U.S. Programmers |
12-May-98 |
U.S. Treasury Has Not Completed Assessment Phase. It's Over. |
12-May-98 |
Treasury Insists It Can Make the Deadline |
12-May-98 |
The Treasury's FMS: Key to the Survival of the Government |
12-May-98 |
Why They Can't Go Back to Pen and Ink Systems |
12-May-98 |
U.S. Governments: 15% Complete |
13-May-98 |
Y2K Czar Describes Council's Role: Coordinating Goo |
13-May-98 |
Rev. Koskinen and the Religion of Senior Management |
13-May-98 |
16 Out of 68 State Agencies in Georgia Submit Y2K Plans |
14-May-98 |
California Will Be Ready: 12/31/98, Says the State |
14-May-98 |
Virginia Agencies Threatened by Y2K, Falling Behind |
18-May-98 |
Utah Claims A Miracle: Y2K Fix for Under $10 Million |
18-May-98 |
Indianapolis Schools Face Y2K Crisis |
19-May-98 |
G-8 Summit Calls for a Y2K Conference |
27-May-98 |
Wyoming: $1 Million of $13 Million Appropriated |
27-May-98 |
Why Every Computerized Government Will Fail in 2000 |
28-May-98 |
Canadian Bureaucrats Predict Failures, Promise Continuity |
28-May-98 |
Y2K Czar Admits: The Truth Might Create a Panic |
28-May-98 |
Gore Is Avoiding Y2K |
28-May-98 |
United Nations Responds to Y2K: Committees Formed |
29-May-98 |
New Zealand's Solution: Set Up a Committee |
29-May-98 |
The Euro: Government Mandates Will Backfire |
31-May-98 |
Systems at Risk: Kappelman's List |
02-Jun-98 |
New Zealand Report Warns of Breakdown in Services |
02-Jun-98 |
European Commission Forms a Committee |
02-Jun-98 |
South Africa Parrots Party Line: Small Government at Risk |
03-Jun-98 |
Congressman Horn Hands out an "F" to the U.S. Government |
05-Jun-98 |
Quebec May Have to Write Checks by Hand |
08-Jun-98 |
Indianapolis: $10 Million, and Few Programmers |
08-Jun-98 |
Japanese Official Says Not to Worry. |
08-Jun-98 |
Canada's Technology Czar Quits |
08-Jun-98 |
TIME Warns: Government Computers Won't Make It |
12-Jun-98 |
The Exodus of the Programmers |
13-Jun-98 |
Y2K Czar Speak With Forked Tongue; Me No Trust |